Feminism and Cultural Exploration in Aurora Leigh - Literature Essay Samples

Victorian literature, like almost all literature, speaks inherently of the social, philosophical and religious issues which molded the people of the time. The Romantic ideals of the singling-out and celebration of the self are often challenged by Victorian literature, with its focus on putting the self into a social context and examining the relationship which emerges. The statement ‘a sense of crisis permeated every aspect of Victorian society as it struggled to reconcile past ideas and beliefs with progress and modernity’ describes this new aspect perfectly. Many changes caused this shift in Victorian society, but one of the most important and controversial was the increasing prominence of women in the public sphere, and the changing dynamics of male-female relationships. It is this revelation which will be explored in this essay, using Aurora Leigh by Elizabeth Barret-Browning as its basis. A book and a line number will be specified after each quotation, and due to th e length of the poem, this essay will focus mainly on the first two books. The Victorian ideal of the angel in the house, a term from a poem by Coventry Patmore, described (when analysed) how women were expected to be subservient to men, and their goals considered to be sublimated upon marriage in favor of helping the husband achieve his goals. Certainly, women were not thought to have much purpose beyond that and child-rearing. In Aurora Leigh, however, this is a central theme and is examined from the very outset of the poem. In Book 1, after Auroras mother dies, her father has to tend to her and this predominantly female-orientated task seems to weigh more heavily on him than on a woman; according to Aurora, women â€Å"know/the way to rear up children† (Browning, 1864, 1. 47) and her father is described as â€Å"Contriving such a miserable smile,/As if he knew needs must, or I should die† (Browning, 1864, 1.98). Having been thrust into this female role, Auroras father is said to have â€Å"through love suddenly/Thrown off the old conventio ns† (Browning, 1864, 1.176) and thus sets up Auroras similar rebellion again society. The death of her mother is used to highlight the problems with the gender constructs of the time; how, she asks, can a man continue to function in his socially-approved place when his wife dies and leaves him all her duties? In this way, Aurora Leigh pokes holes in societys then-dominant ideal of women taking care of the children and doing nothing but support their husbands. It is important to note, however, that Auroras fathers experience is not good. He is described as being somewhat displaced, being â€Å"unmade from a common man/But not completed to an uncommon man† (Browning, 1864, 1.183). Therefore, his departure from social norms left him in a sort of gender purgatory, being neither one thing nor the other. Her fathers example is one of the ways in which this poem depicts the struggle between traditional values and progressive ones in the individual; her father is thrust unwillingly into a progressive role and doesnt ultimately fare well in it. Later in the poem, of course, both Romney and Aurora wilfully disregard societys norms and both fare well, allowing for one minor case of total blindness. So beyond examining tradition versus progression, Aurora Leigh examines the manner in which one comes upon a progressive role, and shows that progression is something of a double-edged sword. Romney ultimately finds love with Aurora but is unable to effect the social change for which he strives, her father becomes a sort of half-mother, caring for his child but uncomfortable with doing so, and Marian Erle becomes a single mother through a horrible experience, but fiercely protects this unconventional status once she has it. Thus, the poem examines not only the crisis in the relationship between the self and society but the internal struggles of progressive change, as well as its pitfalls and the sacrifices which are sometimes necessary. Upon coming to England, Aurora meets her aunt, who is a perfect example of an angel in the house, having lived a â€Å"harmless life, she called a virtuous life† (Browning, 1864, 1.290). Auroras view of her aunt is not flattering but nevertheless perceptive, as she notes that her aunts hair is held tight, â€Å"as if for taming accidental thoughts† (Browning, 1864, 1.275). This could be interpreted as taming her bad thoughts but an alternative interpretation – taming any thoughts – reveals more about what the aunt symbolises in this poem: she is almost entirely without agency. Her â€Å"frigid use of life† (Browning, 1864, 1.277), â€Å"eyes of no colour† (Browning, 1864, 1.283) and a mouth which speaks only of â€Å"unrequited loves† (Browning, 1864, 1.282) all leave her powerless to act of her own accord. She is an object in the poem, not a subject, never directly given voice by Aurora, and in her entirety constitutes a satirical swi pe at the â€Å"angel in the house† paradigm. However, this is not to say that Aurora Leigh is necessarily a feminist work; while it espouses the virtues of female agency, it also contains a large number of hints at a more traditional overarching viewpoint, embodying the Victorian crisis of faith within the work itself. One of these hints comes in the mention of â€Å"ladys Greek,/Without the accents† (Browning, 1864, 2.83), an infantilisation of Auroras intellect which she doesnt challenge. She describes Romneys nature as â€Å"godlike† (Browning, 1864, 1.565), saying afterwards that she is â€Å"a worm† (Browning, 1864, 1.568) in comparison. Another clue is in the fact that her aunt is not given direct voice but others are, perpetuating the idea that only modern women, who have voluntarily entered a male-dominated sphere such as that of Victorian literature, are deserving of a voice. This non-feminist interpretation is explored by critic Deirdre David, who says in Arts A Service; Social Wound, Sexual Polit ics and Aurora Leigh that the â€Å"novel-poem is an integrated expression of essentialist and ultimately non-feminist views of sex and gender, despite sharp attacks on sexual hypocrisy† (David, 1985). It could be said that Auroras desire to become a poet is either an attempt to emulate men, or to beat them at their own game; neither particularly evocative of the feminist ideology of rescinding conventional gender roles. Certainly Auroras desire to write an epic poem (such as Aurora Leigh itself), which is a completely male-dominated area of poetry, shows that she wants to prove herself as good as men; not necessarily an ignoble goal, but nevertheless a goal framed within traditional values. Another point made by David, which could be considered a logical certainty, is that â€Å"to speak of a masculine intellect evidently presupposes a feminine one† (David, 1985) and this is exactly what Aurora does when she says that Romney â€Å"misconceive[s] the question like a man† (Browning, 1864, 2.468). To be able to generalise about men, one must also be able to generalise about women, and Auroras supposition that there is a male mode of thought which always works a certain way implies that there must be a female mode of thought with the same stipulations. Such generalisations are contrary to progressive values and, indeed, to Auroras ability to achieve the task she sets herself. Ultimately, the ideas of feminism and progressive gender values were, during the Victorian era, mixed up and unfocused since they required of the believer such widespread upheaval in the ways they defined gender. This crisis of faith centres entirely around how people viewed gender, and w as a considerable force in the Victorian Era and, especially, on Aurora Leigh. There are striking contrasts in the text, too, between the poems meaning and the poems form. The first example is the use of classical mythological references which would be unknown to most women of the time, such as Auroras description of her mother as â€Å"a dauntless Muse† (Browning, 1864, 1.155) and â€Å"a still Medusa† (Browning, 1864, 1.157). This is another device which shows the changing social ideals of the time; the poem having a female protagonist and yet being peppered with such references. It is almost subterfuge, too, for Aurora Leigh to be an epic poem; traditionally associated with heroic acts of national importance, and dating back to the very birth of poetry, the epic poem usually does not concern itself with subjects like Romneys failed social reformation, and one girls decision to become a poet. In a way, it presupposes its own importance in a way which lends it significant self-referential weight, when viewed in context. The use of the epic poem in particular has additional interpretive relevance; according to critic Herbert F Tucker, in his book Epic, â€Å"the splendor of epic, so the lesson runs, is a glory that was† (Tucker, 2008). While Aurora Leigh could be thought of in this way, to do so would be to ignore its social relevance; writing an epic poem about social reformation implies that the reformation has already happened, and it could be concluded that combining these ideas makes the reader think the same. Something which would compound this assumption is that there is evidence that the epic was falling out of favour in the mid-19th century. Alfred Lord Tennyson himself, in a letter to his publisher Ticknor and Fields, said: â€Å"I should be crazed to attempt [an epic] in the heart of the 19th century† (Tennyson, 1858). To revive an archaic genre in this manner, and in a sense corrupt it to act as both a Bildungsroman and a vehicle for socially progressive views, is to increas e its impact on the reader. The juxtaposition of female content (i.e. having a female protagonist) and male form, combined with all the hitherto-mentioned elements, induces confusion about the gender gap; why is a story of a girl fulfilling her dream less important than an epic battle? Barrett-Brownings poem, however, is in many ways the same as classic epics; the use of classical and biblical references. Perhaps the most meaningful of the latter is in the ending: â€Å"Jasper first, I said,/And second, sapphire; third, chalcedony;/The rest in order, . . last, an amethyst (Browning, 1864, 9.988). This ending, with Auroras and Romneys synergy and a description of the walls of the holy city, creates a powerfully positive image. In itself, it is the marriage of the progressive (Aurora blossoming as a poet) with the traditional (Christian theology), and a very fitting end to the poem as seeing the holy city almost mirrors entering heaven. Even this small study of a small portion of Aurora Leighs representation of the â€Å"crisis of faith† in Victorian society proves it extremely fertile material (much more could be written on this topic alone). The â€Å"third gender† created in Auroras father sets the tone for the remainder of the novel-poem, which sets out to examine Victorian societys emerging feminine literary presence and concludes that they are not only capable, but can also be divinely inspired, as suggested by the ending. This naturally leads to a much wider interpretation than is contained within the poem: if women can be poets, and indeed rival male poets in their own genres, then why cant they do anything else? This shift into the foreground for women was a devastatingly fundamental revelation for every member of Victorian society, and the seeds of feminism sown by Aurora Leigh ultimately germinated into their very own school of thought; changes dont come much more profound than that. Bibliography: Anonymous, 1857, Our Epilogue on Affairs and Books, The British Quarterly Review Vol. XXV. London, Savill and Edwards Printers Barrett, E. B. 1979 [1864] Aurora Leigh ed. J. Miller, London. Reprinted: Chicago: Academy Chicago Printers Brown, S.A., 1997 Paradise Lost and Aurora Leigh, Studies in English Literature 1500-1900 vol. 37 no. 4. Houston, Texas, The Johns Hopkins University Press David, D. 1985 Arts A Service: Social Wound, Sexual Politics and Aurora Leigh, Browning Institute Studies, vol. 3. Cambridge, Mass., Cambridge University Press Stone M. 2010, The Works Of Elizabeth Barrett Browning, ed. Sandra Donaldson. London, Pickering and Chatto Press. Tennyson, A., 1981 [1858] The Letters of Alfred Lord Tennyson, ed. Cecil Y. Lang and Edgar F Shannor, Jr. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press Tucker, H. F. 2008, Epic. New York, USA, Oxford University Press Weber B. R. 2012, Women and Literary Celebrity in the Nineteenth Century. Farnham, Surrey, Ashgate Publishing Limited Zonana, J. 1989, The Embodied Muse: Elizabeth Barrett Brownings Aurora Leigh and Feminist Poetics, Tulsa Studies in Womens Literature, vol. 8 no. 2. Tulsa, Oklahoma. University of Tulsa